Between building relationships and measuring success, let's talk about the practical stuff. The nuts and bolts that make this work.
You're not trying to boil the ocean. You're lighting a match.
Start with: 10-15 quality DMs per week
Why this target?
Week 1-2: 10 DMs total (getting comfortable)Week 3-4: 15 DMs/week (finding your rhythm)Week 5-8: 20 DMs/week (if seeing results)
This gives you 100-150 attempts over 8 weeks. Enough to validate if this channel works for your business.
Someone didn't reply. That's normal. Here's what to do:
One Follow-Up Only:
Good follow-up:"Hey Sarah - just saw [relevant update about their company/post]. Still curious about your experience with [original topic]!"
After no response to follow-up:Move on. Your time is better spent finding new prospects than chasing ghosts. This is a sprint, not a marathon.
DMs are for starting conversations. Sometimes you need to graduate them.
When to suggest a different channel:
Keep it light:"This is fascinating - happy to keep chatting here, but if it's easier, I could send you a quick Loom walking through [specific thing]. Whatever works!"
But remember: many conversions happen entirely in DMs. Don't force channel changes.
You need just enough system to not lose track. Nothing more.
The Minimum Viable Tracker:
That's it. Six columns. One minute per entry.
Why track trigger moments?
Track weekly:
This gives you enough data to know if it's working without becoming a data analyst.
Each platform has unofficial limits. Respect them.
Conservative guidelines for new/young accounts:
Stay safe:
Getting restricted kills your momentum. Better to go slow and steady.
This isn't a forever strategy. It's a 60-90 day sprint to:
Success looks like:
Once you hit these milestones, you graduate to more scalable channels.
What NOT to worry about:
Keep it simple. Keep it moving. You're building momentum, not infrastructure.
Ready to put it all together? Next, we'll show you exactly how to measure success and know when you're ready to move beyond social DMs.